Posted by: christinelaennec | June 7, 2010

Cicely Hamilton on Faith

I recently re-read the 1935 autobiography of Cicely Hamilton (Life Errant).  Hamilton (1872-1952) was a suffragist, actress and writer, and she served as a nurse in France during World War I.  Her novel, William, An Englishman (1919), was the first of the lovely Persephone Books to appear, and is still available through them (click on the link for more info).  It is the story of what happens when fervent idealism meets the hideous reality of war.

I’d remembered enjoying reading her autobiography because of her very independent views on life, and in particular on how people behave in groups.  Her social observations are keen and often ascerbic.  Although she fought for what she believed in, she was never a party-faithful type of person.  I also remembered some terrific ghost stories – she said she never sought out paranormal experiences, but she had some interesting ones nonetheless.

What I hadn’t remembered, and what I particularly enjoyed on this reading, were her thoughts on the importance of faith in God.  She opens her chapter on religion with an anecdote:  she was at a social gathering where people were launched into a discussion of the dangers of religion.  Cecily Hamilton had no argument with this, as she could see very well that religion has done harm as well as good.  But when her companions realised that she wasn’t an atheist, their horror was extreme!

She wrote, about faith:

For those who accept the idea of a God who is righteousness itself, the standard of duty will always be twofold, and one of the unending difficulties of life will consist in the reconciliation of an inward duty towards God, the highest, with an outward duty to the neighbour who is like unto ourselves.  With unbelief, and the passing of God as a factor in our lives, the need for such reconciliation disappears, and there remains only the clash between our instinct for personal advantage and the duty we owe to our neighbour.  At first sight this substitution of a single for a double standard of service would appear to simplify the moral law, and therefore to simplify life; actually, by the process, we lose more than we gain – our contact with absolute truth . . .

If God be indeed an invention of the human mind, we may surmise that humanity invented and adored him because it had need of an uprightness of truth that was not to be found amongst the pliable virtues of men.  Whatever else the acceptance of God may mean in our lives, this is must mean without a doubt:  there is a Being – a Something – call It what you will – to whom it is impossible to lie.  Of none among men can that magnificent ‘impossible’ be said!  Which among us, however desirous of honesty, does not practise petty subterfuge even to his friends?  And – what matters more – does not practise it in flattery to himself?  But to lift up your heart to God, even for a moment, is to place yourself, for that moment, in a Presence that annihilates deceit.  Thou, God, seest me as in very truth I am, as no man on earth has ever seen me.

(Cicely Hamilton, Life Errant, p. 258)

It’s funny to me that her companions were so aghast at her being a believer.  I have friends who are confirmed athiests, and I respect them, just as they respect me.  What horrifies me is the idea that anyone would presume to tell someone what to believe about such mysteries.  I agree with what Cecily Hamilton wrote – but I think the big question, in a world with so much pain and suffering, is her starting assumption:  that God is righteousness, and absolute truth, itself.

And here endeth the (inconclusive) lesson!

(Maybe we’ll have more about the ghost stories later?)



  1. Hi,
    I stumbled across your blog in attempt to find a copy of “Life Errant”. Thank you for the details! It is nice to get a glimpse of what’s inside this elusive book. I’m writing my graduate thesis on Cicely Hamilton and am desperately trying to find a copy of “Life Errant” which seems to be out of print and very, very difficult to find, so thanks for the brief excerpt!

    • Dear Lia,
      How exciting that you’re writing on Cicely Hamilton! I wish you luck with tracking down Life Errant, and with the thesis.

    • Hello,

      Sorry for asking, but, just like Lia, I stumbled across your blog when searching for info on Life Errant.
      Any chance you could put me in touch with Lia – I’m also writing a thesis on Cicely Hamilton.


  2. […] Further Reading: A list of all Persephone Books, Buried in Print’s review, A great mini-bio of Cicely Hamilton, Cicely Hamilton on faith […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: